Skip to main content
Heart School·Wonder·Honor-system

The Magus · Quest for The Paradox of Fiction

The Emotion Engine

The Prompt

Propose a theory of fictional emotions that resolves the paradox without denying any of its three premises (we feel genuine emotions; we know characters are fictional; genuine emotions require existential beliefs). Your theory may draw on cognitive science, philosophy of mind, or aesthetic theory, but it must explain — not explain away — the reality of the tears.

Completion Criteria

A novel or carefully synthesized theory that addresses all three horns of the paradox, explains the mechanism by which fiction generates genuine emotion, and anticipates at least one serious objection.

Claim this quest

Students who have attested

No Students have attested this quest yet. Be the first.